Attributed to Borman workshop and Renier van Thienen (I), Ten Weepers from the Tomb of Isabella of Bourbon (1436–1465), circa 1475–76, after restoration. Bronze. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, on loan from the City of Amsterdam. Courtesy of Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam.
Restoration of These 10 “Weepers” from the Tomb of Isabella of Bourbon Initiates Extensive Research into Sculpture Casting at the Rijksmuseum
The restoration supported by the TEFAF Museum Restoration Fund led to new insights into 15th and 16th-century casting practices
- By TEFAF Editors
- Museum Restoration Fund
With its holdings of over one million objects, the Rijksmuseum chronicles the story of 800 years of Dutch art and history, as well as major aspects of European and Asian art. In 2012, the TEFAF Museum Restoration Fund supported the Rijksmuseum’s restoration of several significant works from its collection: the ten remaining pleurants, or Weepers sculptures (circa 1475–76) of the Antwerp tomb of Isabella of Bourbon, wife of Charles the Bold, Duke of Burgundy.
While traveling to reunite with her husband following the battle of Monthlhéry in 1465, Isabella succumbed to tuberculosis at Saint Michael’s Abbey in Antwerp; her daughter, Mary of Burgundy, commissioned a funeral monument in her honor. Attributed to founder Renier van Thienen and the workshop of sculptor Jan Borman, the monument consisted of a bronze effigy of Isabella herself decorated with 24 “weepers,” statuettes symbolizing the importance of the Burgundy dynasty through the likeness of family members and ancestors. In 1566, the sculptures were looted during the Iconoclast rising—ten Weepers made their way to Amsterdam in the 17th century and have been on loan to the museum since 1887.
On the left, white and orange paint spots on one of the Weepers sculptures. On the right, the sculpture after treatment. Courtesy of Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam.
The Rijksmuseum pursued the restoration of its ten Weepers in the museum’s conservation lab in 2012. Over time, the sculptures suffered from white and orange paint spots from an unknown source, some of which were deeply embedded in their patina. After an analysis of their materials, based on x-ray fluorescence (XRF) technique and inspection with ultra-violet light, the sculptures were carefully cleaned with a scalpel and picker and locally retouched in preparation for their display in the permanent collection of the renovated Rijksmuseum, which opened in 2013.
The 2012 restoration project did not only prepare the Weepers to go back on display in the museum’s galleries—it initiated more extensive material research, which continues to this day. “The treatment provided an opportunity to study traces of manufacturing techniques, leading to the hypothesis that these bronzes were cast according to a hitherto unknown process,” shares Arie Pappot, researcher at the Rijksmuseum. Technical research points to the possibility that different molding and casting methods were used by Van Thienen than common in the Netherlands during that period, which could lead to a fundamentally new insight regarding the casting of sculpture during the 15th and 16th century. “The Weepers, as well as the effigy of Isabella, were examined with x-ray imaging, alloy analysis, and visual inspection to determine key steps in the manufacturing process: the use of models and molds, the construction and suspension of the casting core, and the way the cast pieces were assembled,” Pappot explains. “A thorough review of contemporary documents was conducted to establish the modus operandi of Netherlandish brass foundries and their cooperation with sculptors and wood carvers, leading to the conclusion that the Weepers were cast in loam molds taken directly from wooden models, without the use of an intermodel made of wax—the default process in French and Italian casting traditions.”
The Ten Weepers from the Tomb of Isabella of Bourbon (1436–1465) on display in the Rijksmuseum’s permanent collection. Courtesy of Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam.